Another Day, Another Lawsuit: Davenport Targets Trump’s DHS Over Delaney Hall

NEWARK, N.J. — New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport is taking the Trump administration back to federal court, this time accusing the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) of stonewalling a state investigation into conditions at Newark’s controversial Delaney Hall immigration detention facility. 

The lawsuit announced Tuesday (November 17th) concerns an investigative subpoena issued in August by the New Jersey Division on Civil Rights to GEO Group, the private company operating the federal immigration detention center. This is only the latest in a growing number of politically motivated legal actions aimed by the Democratic administration at the White House.

Davenport’s office is investigating allegations of inadequate medical care, unsafe conditions, and other potential civil rights violations following the deaths of at least three detainees.

GEO Group maintains that it cannot release the requested records without federal authorization. According to the state, DHS has neither granted nor denied that authorization despite more than three months of follow-up requests.

“There are far too many reports of inhumane treatment of the people held at Delaney Hall. But what we have received for months from both GEO Group and DHS is plain stonewalling,” Davenport said.

The latest complaint invokes the federal Administrative Procedure Act, alleging that DHS has unreasonably delayed its response. The state is asking a federal judge to require DHS to make a decision on the records request as opposed to immediately ordering the production of every document sought by investigators.

The distinction matters. While the Attorney General’s Office portrays the dispute as another example of federal obstruction, the lawsuit also highlights an unresolved jurisdictional disagreement between New Jersey officials and federal immigration authorities.

Davenport maintains that GEO Group, as a private company operating inside New Jersey, should comply with state investigative demands without first obtaining Washington’s permission. GEO Group has taken a different position, citing federal regulations governing the disclosure of information connected to DHS operations.

The latest litigation arrives amid an increasingly contentious confrontation over Delaney Hall, which reopened for federal immigration detention operations in 2025. In June, Davenport sued GEO Group on behalf of the New Jersey Department of Health after state inspectors were denied full access to portions of the facility. That separate case remains in litigation.

Governor Mikie Sherrill has also publicly called for Delaney Hall’s closure, making the facility a centerpiece of her administration’s opposition to President Donald Trump’s immigration enforcement policies.

The latest complaint does not establish that DHS or GEO Group violated detainees’ civil rights, nor does the federal government’s failure to respond establish that the underlying allegations are true.

The broader political context is also difficult to ignore. Sherrill’s administration has repeatedly challenged federal immigration enforcement in New Jersey, and Delaney Hall has become a highly visible flashpoint in that conflict.

For now, the courts will have to determine whether DHS has unlawfully delayed its response—and how far New Jersey’s investigative authority extends into a federally contracted immigration detention operation.

The Staff
About The Staff 3284 Articles
SaveJersey.com's Network of Contributors keeps you up-to-date on everything worth knowing in the Garden State. You're welcome!