OPINION: If elected, Phil Murphy won’t live within New Jersey’s means

Democratic gubernatorial candidate Phil Murphy recently laid out his proposed plan for a series of costly tax hikes. Under Murphy’s plan, taxes would rise by $1.3 billion, according to estimates provided by campaign officials. Murphy proposes raising the personal income tax, legalizing and taxing the sale of marijuana, and changing the way personal and corporate income taxes are calculated.

The largest share of the tax hike comes from raising New Jersey’s income tax. The top marginal income tax rate would rise from 8.97 percent to 10.75 percent and could amount to $600 million in tax revenue. Raising the top income tax rate to 10.75 percent would make it the second highest rate in the nation. Only California’s rate of 13.3 percent would be higher.

Increasing taxes will make it harder for New Jersey to attract entrepreneurs and businesses. New Jersey ranked last on the Tax Foundation’s State Business Tax Climate Index which compares states’ tax systems. In addition to high income taxes, New Jersey has the 8th highest corporate income tax and the highest property taxes in the country.

Raising the top income tax rate will solidify New Jersey’s reputation as the highest taxed state in the country.

High taxes might be one reason why people are moving out of New Jersey. United Van Lines’ 2016 United Movers Study found that 63% of the people who contacted them for services were leaving the state. That’s the highest outbound rate in the country. Census migration data shows a similar story. For the last 5 years, more people have moved out of New Jersey than into the state.

New Jersey saw last year just how shaky the state’s revenue can be when it depends so heavily on top-income earners. When it was reported last year that one of New Jersey’s top taxpayers might move, state budget forecasters warned it could cause a $140 million revenue gap. Moreover, the top 1% of New Jersey taxpayers account for around a third income tax collections. Making this group pay more in taxes could send them packing to other states, further harming the state economy.

Beyond individuals, businesses could leave the state if Murphy’s plan for combined reported goes into effect. Combined reporting treats all affiliated businesses that a company owns as one taxpayer. Under combined reporting, a New Jersey company could pay taxes on businesses it holds in other states. Trying to tax a company’s out of state operations is a sure-fire way to make New Jersey less desirable for any companies thinking about moving here.

But in the long-run, combined reporting doesn’t even lead to more revenue for states — just more complexity. A study from the Indiana Legislative Services Agency found that the revenue impact from combined report “will decline to zero” in the long run.

Instead of raising taxes, a better approach would be to live within our state’s means.

New Jersey is expected to gain an extra billion dollars in revenue from its existing tax base. But apparently a billion dollars more isn’t enough. Instead, Murphy’s plan sets out to raise taxes by another $1.3 billion in one of the highest taxed states in the country. 

Murphy’s Tax Increases:

  • $600 million from raising the top marginal tax rate from 8.97 percent to 10.75 percent.
  • $300 million from legalizing and taxing Marijuana
  • $290 million from moving to combined reporting on the corporate income tax
  • $100 million from carried interest tax.
  • $1.3 billion in total tax increases

Erica Jedynak
About Erica Jedynak 29 Articles
ERICA JEDYNAK is the COO for yes. every kid., a leading national advocacy organization w⁠i⁠⁠t⁠h a fam⁠i⁠l⁠i⁠es-f⁠i⁠rs⁠t⁠ approach ⁠t⁠o ⁠t⁠ransform education, where she oversees public affairs and business operations. She lives in Morris County with her husband and son.